My previous entry presented various statistics explaining that while very few poor people have access to savings accounts, there is a strong desire to utilize such financial schemes. It is estimated that 3 out of 4 adults in developing and middle income countries do not have bank accounts and worldwide, it is the poor, women, and rural residents who are the least banked. Only about 10 percent of the 2.5 billion people living on less than $2 per day have access to a bank account. Rather than illustrating a dire picture, these statistics demonstrate the opportunity that exist in broadening savings services to a large segment of the most underserved people worldwide; otherwise known as financial inclusion. (Photo: Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation)
At the Global Savings Forum in Seattle, the first global gathering focused on the role of savings in the developing world, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation pledged $500 million over the next five years to expand savings. Foundation co-chair Melinda French Gates noted that a package of six new grants totaling $40 million are part of the $500 million pledge. The grants support projects and partnerships to improve access to savings and other financial services, including:
Expansion of bank and microfinance services to include savings accounts;
Implementation of new approaches to reach the poor with savings, such as branchless banking and mobile money; and
Research to identify how people use formal and informal financial tools, including savings, credit, insurance, and payment services, and to analyze the impact of financial services on the lives of the poor.
“Savings doesn’t just help people mitigate the risks posed by a medical emergency or a bad crop,” said Mrs. Gates. “It also gives them the ability to marshal their resources to build something better for themselves and their children. It allows them to fund their own businesses, to look ahead with confidence. Savings helps families to take the giant leap from reacting to events to planning for a healthier, happier future.”
Explained by a Gates Foundation press release, “Technologies such as mobile phones are already providing safe, reliable, and easy options for people to access financial services. Sixty-nine percent of the developing world already has a mobile connection, and this number is expected to climb to 98 percent within five years.”
Emerging technologies such as mobile phones and innovations that enable banking services to be provided in post offices, neighborhood shops, and other convenient locations are creating a historic opportunity to deliver affordable, quality financial services to the doorsteps of the world’s poor. In Kenya, a service called M-PESA allows nearly 12 million people to transfer money and link to bank accounts using mobile phones. In Mexico, a network of government-operated convenience stores is serving as a platform to offer banking services to the rural poor. In Malawi, a bank is reaching thousands of first-time banking customers by mounting mobile banks on the back of pickup trucks. Here is a video detailing the Foundation’s program of promoting financial inclusion in Mexico:
From November 16-17, 2010, the Seattle, Washington-based Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation hosted the Global Savings Forum, the first global gathering focused on the role of savings in the developing world urging urged leaders in government, banking, mobile communications, and international development to work together to build a new kind of financial infrastructure to bring savings to the poor. The conference produced several interesting statistics about the unbanked—people who do not have access to a savings account.
It is estimated that 3 out of 4 adults in developing and middle income countries do not have bank accounts and worldwide, it is the poor, women, and rural residents who are the least banked. Only about 10 percent of the 2.5 billion people living on less than $2 per day have access to a bank account. Sub-Saharan Africa is the least banked region in the world with 80 percent of its population lacking access to a bank account. This is followed by the Middle East/North Africa and Latin America/Caribbean at 68 and 65 percent, respectively.
There is a misconception that poor people do not save. The truth is that poor people actively save in cash and through informal mechanisms, but these tools inadequately meet their specific needs. According to a series of studies, over the course of a year, a typical poor household in Bangladesh, India or South Africa uses no less than four and typically closer to ten types of financial instruments. Rotating Savings and Credit Association (ROSCA) membership rates among adults have been estimated at between 50 and 95 percent of adults in Cameroon, Côte d'Ivoire, Democratic Republic of Congo, Gambia, Liberia, Nigeria, and Togo and similar group savings schemes are widespread outside of Africa as well. (ROSCA is a group of individuals who agree to meet for a defined period of time in order to save and borrow together.) Furthermore, a study of 1,500 people in Uganda showed that 99 percent of respondents failed to reach their savings goals when using informal methods, either because the money was stolen or lost, or because they were too tempted to spend the money when it was stored as cash in their home.
The conference presented overwhelming evidence that savings accounts are in high demand by poor people. Interestingly, savings accounts are being engaged at rates up to 12:1 compared to loans, even when both services are available from the same institution. In Uganda, for example, 43 percent of people said a savings account is their greatest financial need compared to 31 percent who cited credit. A Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (CGAP) study of six microsavings-focused institutions also found rapid growth in savers. During a six-year time period, 20 million new accounts and $4.3 billion in savings volume were added, representing an increase of 87 percent and 71 percent respectively.
Several participants noted that safe savings options help people to manage risks, like illness, increase investment in livelihoods, and empower women. A study in the Philippines showed that access to certain savings products increased women’s economic empowerment, including decision-making power over purchases, family planning, and children’s education. Farmers who were given the option to put aside money toward the next planting season increased productivity, enhancing investments in farming inputs by 32-39 percent. A randomized control trial in Western Kenya found that women who had access to a formal savings account were able to save and invest 45 percent more in their businesses after six months, leading to increased purchasing power for food and personal expenditures. The same study revealed that women with formal savings accounts were better able to afford emergency health services without depleting the money invested in their businesses. For most poor households, using savings to pay for large expenditures is cheaper and more efficient than taking a loan. For instance, even microfinance institutions (MFIs) often charge over 50 percent annual interest on loans. Fees for small deposit accounts, however, often equate to zero or positive interest payments to savers.
Poor households with access to savings accounts are more likely to invest in education, increase productivity and income, and reduce vulnerability to illness and other unexpected events. The challenge remains that very few MFIs offer savings accounts, and more than 90 percent of the world’s poor still lack access to financial services and resort to risky, expensive, and inefficient ways to save. In my next blog entry, I will present a number of solutions discussed during the two-day forum that will increase savings mechanisms to a large underserved market.