Produced annually by the EY Center for Board Matters, the 2022 report presents a list of relevant and timely questions, segmented by four themes, for a company's board of directors to consider:
Theme 1: Strategy and innovation - Strategy that positions companies to innovate and differentiate for a sustainable future
- How is the company rethinking its definition of "long term" to maximize value while also focusing on near-term risks and opportunities? Is the strategy appropriately focused not only on where the company is going, but where it can go?
- Are material environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues considered in the company's long-term strategic planning? How do the company's business model, practices, products, and services address urgent environmental and social challenges as we move toward a more inclusive and sustainable future?
- What data and metrics are being used to assess the health and vibrancy of the organization's culture and its alignment with strategy? Is the culture appropriate to inspire and enable innovation?
- Is the company's capital allocation aligned with the necessities of its long-term strategy? How is the company addressing barriers toward optimal allocation?
- Does the board have the appropriate governance process to oversee strategic investments that seed innovation to change the game? How is it supporting the acceleration of idea generation, trialing and assessment while also encouraging appropriate risk-taking?
- Has management appropriately considered partnerships, joint ventures and alliances, along with M&A, to accelerate the strategy, particularly with longer-term adjacent and transformational opportunities?
- Are newer and innovative technologies, including digital platforms and cryptocurrency solutions, appropriately leveraged to accelerate goals and objectives? How can these technologies accelerate the speed to market and enhance virtual collaboration and customer engagement?
- What is the company's transition plan for thriving in a net-zero future? Is that plan integrated with the company strategy? Does it include specific short-, medium-and long-term greenhouse gas reduction targets and related decarbonization initiatives? How is the company preparing for additional climate-related disclosure requirements?
- How is the company investing in protecting and restoring the natural ecosystems and biodiversity on which its business relies?
- Does the board understand the company's supply chain constraints? Is the board confident that the supply network is flexible and agile amid continued global supply chain challenges? How is it addressing increased calls from stakeholders for sustainability and less waste?
Theme 2: Talent oversight - Broader oversight of culture and talent that is prepared for the transforming labor market
- Do scenario analyses consider an appropriate range of extreme and even improbable scenarios, including existential threats? Do they incorporate the potential compounding effects of various risks, such as supply chain disruption, talent acquisition and retention, inflation, future interest rates and an evolving tax landscape?
- Are contingency and response plans related to material and high-impact risks, such as cybersecurity breaches and natural disasters, periodically simulated and reviewed with the board?
- How is the company revisiting and adapting its risk management strategy and management's approach to the three lines model in response to potential changes in the external and internal environment, changes in the strategy and risk landscape, and the company's operating model?
- Has the board considered how the organization's risk assessment capabilities are evolving, including how analytics, artificial intelligence and other emerging technologies can be used to review and validate data and information to unearth insights into enterprise risks and opportunities?
- How has the company's cybersecurity risk management program evolved to address the current environment in which attackers are targeting a larger surface area and using increasingly unpredictable tactics? How are cybersecurity and data privacy considerations proactively integrated into all major strategy or tactical decisions, such as transactions, alliances, new products or services, and technology upgrades?
- What types of data is the organization collecting from its customers and other stakeholders to better assess the trust, risks and opportunities related to changing preferences and needs? How is the collection occurring?
- How is the company scanning and assessing geopolitical developments, including a rapidly changing trade and regulatory landscape and governments moving to a more interventionist policy position?
- What is the company doing to address material social risks across its value chain, including the treatment of employees and suppliers' human rights practices and impacts on customers and the communities in which it operates?
- How is the company assessing the impact of physical and transition climate risks on products and services, supply chains and operations that can materially affect operating costs and revenues across the enterprise?
- Has the organization's tax planning strategy been reevaluated to address potential tax policy changes, as well as impacts arising from potential shifts in the supply chain and capitalization? Has the organization considered growing stakeholder interest in tax transparency and potential related reputational impacts?
- Does the board understand and approve the company's data privacy and data usage policy? How is customer and employee data use managed? Are social surveillance algorithms reviewed for bias? Is data protection considered beyond cybersecurity protection?
Theme 3: Risk and resiliency - Risk management that enables resiliency amid new and evolving challenges
- As the nature of work and employment further transforms, how will the organization adapt its talent functions to realize its strategy? Does the board spend the same amount of time with the chief human resources officer (CHRO) discussing data and metrics to assess the health and welfare of the workforce as it does with the CFO reviewing and assessing the overall financial health and stability?
- To attract and retain talent in a hypercompetitive labor market, how is the organization implementing plans to address calls for better pay and benefits, including flexibility, the opportunity to work from anywhere, programs to enhance well-being, and funding for training and educational advancement?
- How have the desired skills and behaviors for the organization's leaders evolved in response to the events of the last two years, and how has the board's succession planning and oversight of talent development changed in response?
- Given that more than half of employees say they would leave their job if flexibility in their schedule and work location is not extended after the pandemic, has the organization considered how to make flexibility integral to the company's human capital strategy?
- How is the company seizing strategic opportunities to tap into larger talent pools, diversify across numerous dimensions and expand working hours across time zones, while being mindful of work location, regulatory and legislative challenges?
- Is the board comfortable with how the organization is nurturing its existing and future talent pools (e.g., reskilling and upskilling, educational alliances) to position the company to meet current requirements, address enterprise risks and prepare for continued strategic pivots?
- How is company leadership enabling cross-functional collaboration and seeking input from a broader set of internal constituencies to support an inclusive culture, enhance engagement and spur innovation? How are these efforts measured?
- Are there any efforts to identify and address disconnects between how management views the employee experience and the employee's actual experience? Are employee engagement scores, periodic pulse checks, summaries of exit and onboarding interviews, and social media data routinely reviewed?
- With continued virtual work, how is the company addressing any impacts on employee engagement, inclusion and career development?
- How is the company embedding diversity and inclusion into its workplace policies and human capital management programs throughout all steps in the employee life cycle to enable equitable opportunities, advancement and compensation?
Theme 4: Dynamic governance - Dynamic governance that addresses expanded and changing oversight requirements
- How is the board adopting a continual learning mindset and strengthening its education program? Is the program sufficiently tailored to the company's and individual board member's needs, seeking diverse views from inside and outside the company that allow for challenges to status quo thinking?
- How can the board's structure be refreshed to be more agile, future-focused and aligned to the risks and opportunities on the road ahead? Is the board considering the use of ad hoc committees made up of directors, management and third parties to address specific strategic issues?
- How is the compensation committee evolving its charter to address oversight of broader human capital issues? How does the board hold senior management accountable for progress against related goals via incentive plans and other reward mechanisms? How is the company preparing for ongoing human capital disclosure requirements?
- How is the company refreshing its investor engagement strategy to be more efficient and productive? Is it considering new engagement approaches (e.g., more collaborative engagement via working groups or investor days)? Is it leveraging the proxy statement and other disclosures as communication tools?
- How is the board thinking like an activist in considering and proactively addressing the company's operating vulnerabilities? How is the board obtaining an unfiltered view of shareholder feedback on the company's strategy and pace of performance? Do select individual board members have direct dialogue with shareholders to understand their priorities?
- Are information flows to the board being appropriately challenged to include more forward-looking and predictive insights, coverage of emerging risks, external perspectives, and corroborating data from third parties to keep pace with the evolving market, economic and geopolitical developments? Is a consent agenda used to maximize board discussion of strategic initiatives?
- How is the board expanding its director search to maximize diversity and broaden board competencies in critical areas such as technology, human capital management, cybersecurity, and sustainability, and how are those individuals onboarded to set them up for success?
- With increased board diversity, what changes to its protocols are being made to leverage diversity of thought, improve decision-making and create an inclusive boardroom?
- Is the board prepared for increased accountability as ESG matters become a multi-stakeholder priority and investors increasingly embrace proxy votes against directors as their most effective tool to accelerate progress on ESG matters?
- With growing scrutiny of sustainability reporting and stakeholder concerns around greenwashing, how is the board — particularly the audit committee — overseeing nonfinancial disclosures made in regulatory filings, sustainability reports, analyst calls and other mediums? Are internal or external assurance procedures applied to material assertions and data?
- Is the company progressively reporting on human, customer and societal value to attract capital and meet the increasing demand of stakeholders for consistent and comparable ESG and other nonfinancial‑related data that aligns with evolving external frameworks?
- What is the board's policy for timely review of corporate political and lobbying expenditures and any public political positions taken by senior executives? How is the board assessing the alignment of those expenditures and positions with the company's values, commitments and strategy?
- Could the board create more effective meeting agendas and protocols (e.g., consent agendas) to increase director engagement on priority matters? Can virtual sessions augment and enhance traditional in-person meetings?
The report insightfully notes that companies will "continue to refresh their strategy to strengthen agility, resiliency and sustainability and leverage innovative opportunities that can accelerate their performance over the long term." Importantly, "Trajectories of companies that are thriving and leaning into this strategic reset are diverging rapidly from those that are merely surviving."
Moreover, "Boards have both the opportunity and the responsibility to help guide companies in this new era. They can support their companies in incorporating human and natural capital as part of business decisions and strategy, and harness risks as opportunities for innovation and a competitive advantage." I concur that this cannot "be achieved through a historical governance model. Boards should continue their own transformation to a new agile and dynamic form of governance and continuously challenge their composition, committee structure, agendas, and ways of working to position their organizations to thrive in the long term."
I appreciate how EY's report provides directors with insights and questions to consider as they engage with management on a variety of complex boardroom issues. What questions do you think directors should be asking to help companies in this new era?